Thanksgiving Pies & Cheesecakes

Thanksgiving Ordering

Placing a Thanksgiving order with your neighborhood dairy farm is wicked easy! You can either

  • Visit us – we are open 6am-3pm daily on the weekdays, 8am-3pm on weekends.
  • Call 413-586-2142 between open hours to place your order or just leave a message if we are closed – we’ll call you back to confirm
  • Email
    • Please include your name, full order, phone number, pick up date, and pick up time.

Orders placed after 3:00pm on Saturday, November 20 will need baker approval…so why wait? Just place your order now!

Thanksgiving Pies

Apple Crumb
Banana Cream
Chocolate Cream
Coconut Cream
Key Lime
Lemon Meringue
Minced Meat
Mixed Berry
Chocolate Pecan
Peanut Butter Dream
Strawberry Rhubarb


Chocolate Chip
Double Chocolate
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Chocolate Butterscotch
NY Style w/ Cherry
NY Style w/ Blueberry
NY Style w/ Strawberry
Apple Crisp
Peach Crisp
Cinnamon Bun
Cookie Dough
Bailey’s Irish Cream
We are also accepting special requests for cheesecakes.

Pick Up Day Info

  • Due to short staffing, please allow some extra time for your Thanksgiving order pick ups.
  • Barstow’s is open on Wednesday, November 24 from 6am-5pm.
  • Please be ready with the last name of the order so we can retrieve it for you.
  • You are also welcome to pick up orders at the drive thru window. Please stop at the speaker to let us know you have arrived before pulling forward.
  • Planning on grabbing lunch or breakfast when you visit? Or last second grocery items for your table? We are delighted to take your orders when you arrive OR better yet, call ahead!
  • Thank you for your patience as we organize orders and prioritize the health and safety of this community! We are grateful for your order and support!

Signup for Barstow's monthly newsletter