Ice Cream & Dairy

Maple Valley Creamery Ice Cream

Flavors change frequently and with the season!


  • Kiddie2.75
  • Small3.25
  • Medium4.25
  • Large5.25
  • Available in a dish, sugar cone, cake cone, waffle cone (+$)


  • Small5.00
  • Large6.00
  • Includes hot topping, whipped cream, and a cherry
  • Add brownie1.50
  • Add candy0.50

Ice Cream Sandwich

  • Ice Cream Sandwich4.50
  • Choose any two cookies and ice cream


  • Milkshake5.50
  • Choose any Maple Valley flavor!
  • Coffee Float4.50
  • Ice cream and iced coffee
  • Quake5.50
  • Milkshake made with coffee instead of milk
  • Smoothie5.50
  • Banana, Peach, Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry, Frozen Yogurt, Greek Yogurt, Milk, Soy Milk, Juice


  • Pint5.80
  • Quart8.55
  • ½ Gallon10.10

McCray Farm Fresh Milk

Whole, 2%, 1%, Skim, Chocolate

  • Pint1.80
  • ½ Gallon3.78
  • ½ Gallon Flavored4.29
  • Gallon5.06

Cabot Cheese

  • Single Serve0.55
  • Sandwich Sliced3.60
  • Shredded Cheese3.60
  • Cracker Cut4.65
  • 2 lb. Block13.00

  • Butter4.40
  • Cottage Cheese3.00
  • Sour Cream 1lb.3.30
  • Cream Cheese3.25
  • Greek Vanilla Yogurt5.45
  • Greek Plain Yogurt5.45
  • Flavored Dips2.10
  • Spreadable Cheddar5.25
  • Whipped Cream4.25

Vermont Sharp Cheddar
Extra Sharp Cheddar
Seriously Sharp Cheddar
Monterey Jack Cheese
Garlic & Herb
Everything Bagel Cheddar
Smoky Bacon
Tomato Basil
Tuscan Cheddar
Pepper Jack Cheese
Hot Buffalo Wing
Hot Habanero
Legacy Collection | Alpine
Legacy Collection | Farmhouse Reserve
Legacy Collection | New York Vintage
Legacy Collection | White Oak

What’s the deal, a dairy farm that doesn’t sell their own ice cream or milk??

Between the cows, the crops, and the bakery, we have our hands full. But that isn’t a problem when you live in the Pioneer Valley!

We are very happy to support and work with two local dairies.  McCray Farm supplies us with all of our milk for resale and baking with.  Their farm has a processing plant and a small herd of cows in South Hadley, MA.  Maple Valley Creamery makes all of the ice cream we sell at Barstow’s.  Their super premium ice cream comes from local cows and is based in Hadley, MA.

Dairy farmers in this area have been working together for generations.  We offer local products from local cows who are deeply cared for and make really good stuff!

All of the milk produced at Barstow’s Longview Farm goes to the Agri-Mark Cabot Cooperative plant in West Springfield where it is made into Cabot butter, other Cabot products, and liquid milk found in your local grocery store.  You can learn more about this in our blog.

Signup for Barstow's monthly newsletter

Barstow's is open. Call ahead for grocery availability / to place orders: (413) 586-2142(click to view hours)