Bakery

The bakery started as Shannon Barstow's dream.

The bakers are busy every morning keeping cases and orders filled!  All of our baked goodies are whipped up or baked off in house. See what’s new and in season in the bakery case!

Bakery

  • Brownies2.75
  • Cream Cheese, Chocolate Chip
  • Magic Bars3.25
  • Turnovers1.95
  • Apple, Blueberry
  • Cinnamon Swirls3.65
  • Pan of Swirls8.00
  • Croissants1.85
  • Filled Croissant2.65
  • Chocolate, Strawberry Cheese
  • Scones2.50
  • Cinnamon, Seasonal
  • Muffins2.00
  • Raspberry, Blueberry, Mixed Berry, Cranberry Nut, Cinnamon Apple, Corn, Chocolate Chip, Seasonal
  • Mini Loaf7.00
  • Seasonally: Banana, Banana Nut, Rhubarb, Zucchini, Pumpkin, Seasonal
  • Danishes3.25
  • Cherry, Blueberry, Apple, Cheese
  • Cookies0.85 each
  • .3 for 2.55
  • .6 for 5.00
  • Chocolate Chip, M&M, Snicker Doodles, Ginger Snaps, Oatmeal Raisin, Oatmeal Craisin, Peanut Butter, White Chocolate Macadamia, Chocolate PB Chip
  • Macaroons1.00-1.12 each
  • Cow Plops1.00 each
  • No bake chocolate and peanut butter cookies
  • Granola Bites4.00
  • Cupcakes3.00
  • Chocolate, Vanilla, Carrot Cake
  • Mini Cupcakes0.85
  • Chocolate, Vanilla, Carrot Cake
  • Seasonal Specialty Bars3.25
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter, Key Lime, Lemon, Strawberry Rhubarb, Blueberry Pie, Apple Pie, other Seasonal
  • Cheesecake Cup3.00
  • Plain, Blueberry, Cherry, Specialty
  • Whoopie Pie3.80

Visit our party platter page for a variety of sweets for your next birthday, business meeting, or special event! 

Shannon uses Grandma’s pie recipes.

Try the same pies that have been enjoyed by generations of Barstow’s – homemade with flaky crust of course!

Pies..........Slice / Whole

All pies available on a seasonal basis

  • Apple Pie3.80 / 15.50
  • Apple Crumb Pie3.80 / 15.50
  • Banana Cream Pie*3.60 / 14.50
  • Blueberry Pie4.20 / 18.50
  • Cherry Pie3.60 / 14.50
  • Chocolate Cream Pie3.60 / 14.50
  • Chocolate Pecan Pie*4.30 / 19.00
  • Key Lime Pie*3.80 / 15.50
  • Lemon Meringue*4.20 / 17.50
  • Minced Meat*3.80 / 15.50
  • Mixed Berry*4.20 / 17.50
  • Pecan Pie*4.20 / 18.50
  • Peach Pie4.20 / 17.50
  • Peanut Butter Dream*4.20 / 17.50
  • Pumpkin Pie3.80 / 15.50
  • Rhubarb3.80 / 15.50
  • Strawberry Rhubarb4.20 / 18.50
*Pies typically only available special ordered

Place an order with us for your next special event!

Birthdays, celebrations, just because, there’s always a good reason for cake!  All cake orders require a minimum of 48 hours notice.

Standard Cakes

Simple piping, flowers, and minimal text. Orders may be taken by any staff.

  • Heart Cake | 2-4 servings15.00
  • 6” Round | 6-8 servings21.00
  • 8” Round | 8-10 servings23.00
  • ¼ Sheet | 12-15 servings25.00
  • 3/8 Sheet | 20-25 servings35.00
  • ½ Sheet | 25-30 servings45.00

Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble
Frosting: Chocolate, Cream Cheese, Vanilla
Fillings: Strawberry, Raspberry, Whipped Cream
+ $2 for 6” |+ $3 for 8” |+ $5 for ¼ + $6 for 3/8 |+ $8 for ½

Standard Carrot Cake

Simple piping, flowers, and minimal text. Orders may be taken by any staff.

  • Heart Cake | 2-4 servings18.00
  • 6” Round | 6-8 servings24.00
  • 8” Round | 8-10 servings27.00
  • ¼ Sheet | 12-15 servings30.00
  • 3/8 Sheet | 20-25 servings43.00
  • ½ Sheet | 25-30 servings53.00

*Carrot Cake contains nuts and comes with cream cheese frosting unless otherwise stated.

Gluten Free cake options available. Please call and speak with a baker for more information.

Specialty Cakes

Orders must be taken by a baker.

  • 8” Round42.00
  • ¼ Sheet44.00
  • 3/8 Sheet54.00
  • ½ Sheet62.00

Special requests which require additional time and materials start with an up-charge of $20. Depending upon the time and detail required there may be additional charges. Each cake will be evaluated on a cake by cake basis.

    Cheesecake

  • Plain34.00
  • Chocolate Chip34.00
  • Double Chocolate34.00
  • Cow Spots34.00
  • Pumpkin34.00
  • Turtle36.50
  • Bailey’s Irish Cream36.50

We keep our Grab and Go cooler stocked with individual cheesecake slices. All whole cheesecakes must be special ordered with at least 24 hours advance notice.

Nothing goes better with sweets than a hot cup of local coffee or tea!

And, we ask....can you really enjoy a cookie without a glass of milk?!

Beverages

Rao’s Coffee
Sm. 2.50 | Med. 3.00 | Lg. 3.50
Barstow’s Blend, Dark Roast, Decaf, Flavor of the Day
  • Your own mug2.50
  • Iced Coffee2.60
  • Tea1.85
  • Classic Black, English Breakfast, Chai Marsala, Earl Grey, Green, Lemon Ginger, Chai Green, Ginger Peach w/ Matcha, Organic Chamomile, Peppermint, Licorice Spice, Classic Black DeCaf, Green DeCaf, Earl Grey DeCaf, African Rooibos Red, Pure Organic White
  • Chai Tea2.65
  • Hot, Iced
 
  • Hot Chocolate2.00
  • Milk1.80
  • Whole, Chocolate
  • Coffee Float4.50
  • Ice cream and iced coffee
  • Quake5.50
  • Milkshake made with coffee instead of milk
  • Smoothies5.50
  • Banana, Peach, Strawberry, Blueberry, Raspberry, Frozen Yogurt, Greek Yogurt, Milk, Soy Milk, Juice
  • Milkshakes5.50
  • Any Maple Valley Creamery flavor!

Signup for Barstow's monthly newsletter

Barstow's is open daily 'til 4pm; Drive Thru ONLY. Call for grocery availability and to place orders: (413)-586-2142