Prepared Foods

  • Whole Quiche25.00
  • select cheese, meat(s), veggie(s) to customize your quiche
  • Tomato Pie26.00
  • Macaroni and Cheese/pan45.00/pan
  • Regular, Spicy, Specialty (+$)
  • Corn Bread22.00/pan
  • Ched. Jalap. Corn Bread24.50/pan
  • Pierogi Prepared35.00/dz
  • Potato Cheese, Cabbage, Cabbage Kielbasa, sauteed with onions
  • Shepherd's Pie50.00/pan
  • 9" Chicken Pot Pie Prepared36.00
  • Lasagna57.00/pan
  • Meat, Veggie
  • Baked Ziti45.00/pan
  • Meat, Veggie
  • Stuffed Shells57.00/pan
  • Seasoned Chicken Breast9.79/lb
  • Chicken Tenders8.09/lb
  • Meatloaf9.99/lb
  • Meatballs12.29/lb
  • Available in red sauce or Swedish style
  • Sweet and Sour Kielbasa9.99/lb
  • Squash Casserole49.00/pan
  • Roasted Onion Potatoes40.00/pan
  • Mashed Potatoes45.00/pan
  • Roasted Seasonal Vegetables45.00/pan

Frozen Grocery

  • Soup and Chili12.00/qt
  • Pierogi Frozen18.50/dz
  • Potato Cheese, Cabbage, Cabbage Kielbasa | handmade pierogi are boiled and only require sauteeing
  • 9" Chicken Pot Pie Frozen32.00
  • 6" Chicken Pot Pie Frozen20.00
  • Meatballs13.25
  • Sweedish style; available in red sauce by special order
  • Chicken Tenders7.99/lb

Homemade Soups

  • Homemade Soup12.00/qt
  • Clam Chowder12.00/qt
  • Barstow's Famous Chili12.00/qt
  • 1 quart serves ~4 people
    New England Clam Chowder, Cheddar Corn Chowder, Barstow's Famous Chili, Tomato Cheddar, Potato Cheddar, Broccoli Cheddar, Asparagus Cheddar, Chicken Veggie, Chicken Rice, Butternut Squash, Pumpkin Corn, Irish Beef Stew, and other seasonal soups (Please ask if you have a special request!)

Cheese and Cracker Platter

  • 12 in41.00
  • 18 in60.00
  • Includes three types of cheese and crackers to go with the cheese.
Cheese choices: Colby jack, pepper jack, habanero, garlic herb, sharp cheddar, extra sharp cheddar, cracked peppercorn, and Vermont cheddar

Veggie Platter

  • 12 in43.00
  • 18 in55.00
  • Assorted vegetables served with veggie or ranch dip

    Fruit Platter

  • 12 in48.00
  • 18 in68.50
  • Assorted, colorful fruits arranged on a platter

Picnic Salads

  • Chicken Salad8.64/lb
  • Egg Salad5.74/lb
  • Potato Salad6.24/lb
  • Pasta Salad5.94/lb
  • Italian Pasta Salad6.24/lb
  • Artichoke-Chickpea Salad7.74/lb
  • Quinoa Salad8.84/lb
  • Fruit Salad7.94/lb
  • Green Salad7.94/lb
  • dressing packets (+0.25)
  • Coleslaw5.54/lb
  • Blue Cheese Slaw5.64/lb
Picnic salads seasonally available in our Grab n'Go cooler or for special order year round

Perfect for entertaining, lunch meetings, picnics, or the last minute pot-luck!

Lunch Orders for Groups

Finger Sandwich Platter

  • 18 in. | 25 servings70.00
  • 25 finger sandwiches of your choice
    Egg Salad, Chicken Salad, Ham Salad, Tuna Salad, Hummus & Veggie

Sandwich Platter

  • 12 in. | 6-8 servings61.00
  • 5 sandwiches of your choice
  • 18 in. | 12–16 servings117.00
  • 10 sandwiches of your choice

Sandwiches are cut into ¼’s and wraps are cut into ½’s.  You may choose any sandwiches from our specialty sandwich offerings or build your own. Here are our most popular:

Shermanator │ wheat bread, turkey, ham, bacon, Cabot cheddar cheese, mayo, lettuce & tomato
Uncle Fuzzy │ multi-grain bread, roast beef, horseradish cheddar cheese, horseradish mayo, lettuce, tomato & red onion
Farmhand │ wheat bread, turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, apples, & Dijon
Barstow BLAT │ rye bread, Swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, & mayo
Garden Sandwich│ bagel, hummus, Cabot Muenster, cucumber, tomato, shredded carrot, red peppers, & onion
The Barstownian │ rye bread, honey mustard, Swiss cheese, ham, lettuce, & tomato
Funky Chicken │ tortilla Wrap filled with chicken salad, lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, & Muenster cheese
Hummus Wrap │ white wrap, hummus, cucumber, lettuce, tomato, onion, carrot, & red peppers 
Remillard | wheat bread, turkey, American cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, & onion 

We will accommodate special sandwich requests.

Bagged Lunches

  • Simple Bagged Lunch11.50 each
  • Includes a sandwich (turkey, ham, or veggie, with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and onion on wheat), and a chocolate chip cookie
  • All That Bagged Lunch13.50 each
  • Includes a sandwich (turkey, ham, or veggie, with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and onion on wheat), a bag of chips, and a chocolate chip cookie
  • Gluten Free Bread+0.75 each
  • Specialty Sandwiches+0.60 each

Build Your Own Sandwich Options

Prices vary. Please contact us for the most current prices.

Sliced Meat Platters - 12 in. or 18 in. round platter of Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Salami, Pepperoni

Bread Platters - 18 in. round platter including a variety of breads
Whole Wheat, Multi-grain, White, Rye, Sun-dried Tomato Wraps, Wheat Wraps, Flour Wraps

Sliced Cheese Platters - Mild Cheddar, American, Swiss, Provolone, Horseradish Cheddar, Muenster

Sliced Tomato Platter - 12 in. round platter with fresh sliced tomatoes. Perfect for build your own burgers or sandwiches.

Lettuce or Onion Platter - 12 in. round platter with either Lettuce or Onions. Perfect for build your own burgers or sandwiches.

Desserts for Groups

Cookie Platter

  • 12 in27.50
  • 2 dozen cookies of your choice
  • 18 in58.50
  • 5 dozen cookies of your choice

    Mini Cookie Platter

  • 12 in36.00
  • 72 mini cookies of your choice
  • 18 in60.50
  • 180 mini cookies of your choice

    Moo Moo (chocolate cookie with white chocolate chips), Grandma Barstow’s Chocolate Chip, M&M, Chocolate with Peanut Butter Chips, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Peanut Butter, Oatmeal Craisin, Oatmeal Raisin, Ginger Snaps, Snicker Doodles.
    We also have 2 gluten free cookie options (peanut butter and macaroons) the macaroons are available with a chocolate drizzle.

    Brownie/Magic Bar Platter

    Just Brownies:
  • 12 in. |72 brownie bites41.00
  • 18 in. | 108 brownie bites55.50
  • Half Brownies, half Magic Bars:
  • 12 in. |72 brownie bites52.50
  • 18 in. | 108 brownie bites69.00

  • Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate with Peanut Butter Chips, or Cream Cheese
    Magic Bars (sweet layered bars with coconut, butterscotch chips, chocolate chips, gram cracker crumbs, and chopped walnuts)

    Mini Muffin Platter

  • 12 in35.00
  • 18 in51.00
  • Blueberry, Raspberry, Mixed Berry, Cranberry Nut, Banana Nut, Apple Cinnamon, Bran, Corn, Chocolate Chip

Mini Pastry Platter

  • 12 in41.50
  • 18 in60.50
  • Mini Danish, Mini Cinnamon Swirl, Mini Turnover, Muffins, Scones
    Choices for platter may be just one variety of pastry, or may be assorted

    Mini Cheesecake Platter

  • 12 in46.50
  • 18 in84.50
  • Mini cheesecake cups with your choice of Blueberry or Cherry topping

    Cupcake Platters

    Mini Cupcake Platter
  • 12 in. | 30 mini cupcakes29.00
  • 18 in. | 60 mini cupcakes58.00
  • Large Cupcakes3.95 each
  • Medium Cupcakes3.00 each
  • Cake: Vanilla, Chocolate, Carrot Cake
    Frosting: Chocolate, Butter Cream
    Available with or without sprinkles, different frosting colors available.
    Any quantity is available for large and medium sized cupcakes.

    Assorted Mini Dessert Platter

  • 12 in55.50
  • 18 in70.50
  • Cupcakes, Cookies, Cheesecake, Brownies, Assorted Bars

Standard Cakes

Simple piping, flowers, and minimal text. Orders may be taken by any staff.

  • Heart Cake | 6-8 servings29.00
  • 6” Round | 6-8 servings29.00
  • 8” Round | 8-10 servings32.00
  • ¼ Sheet | 12-15 servings35.00
  • 3/8 Sheet | 20-25 servings45.00
  • ½ Sheet | 25-30 servings55.00

Flavors: Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble
Frosting: Chocolate, Cream Cheese, Vanilla
Fillings (+$): Strawberry, Raspberry, Whipped Cream

Standard Carrot Cake

Simple piping, flowers, and minimal text. Orders may be taken by any staff.

  • Heart Cake | 6-8 servings32.00
  • 6” Round | 6-8 servings32.00
  • 8” Round | 8-10 servings36.00
  • ¼ Sheet | 12-15 servings40.00
  • 3/8 Sheet | 20-25 servings53.00
  • ½ Sheet | 25-30 servings63.00

*Carrot Cake contains nuts and comes with cream cheese frosting unless otherwise stated.

Gluten Free cake options available. Please call and speak with a baker for more information.


  • Plain45.00
  • Chocolate Chip45.00
  • Double Chocolate45.00
  • Pumpkin45.00
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter45.00
  • Chocolate Butterscotch45.00
  • NY Style w/ Fruit Compote48.00
  • NY Style w/ Fruit Crisp48.00
  • Coconut48.00
  • Cinnamon Bun48.00
  • Cookie Dough48.00
  • Turtle48.00
  • Bailey’s Irish Cream48.00
  • Custom Order48.00

We keep our bakery stocked with individual cheesecake slices. All whole cheesecakes must be special ordered with at least 48 hours advance notice.


All pies available on a seasonal basis

  • Apple Pie20.00
  • Apple Crumb Pie20.00
  • Banana Cream Pie20.00
  • Blueberry Pie24.00
  • Cherry Pie19.00
  • Chocolate Cream Pie20.00
  • Chocolate Pecan Pie24.00
  • Key Lime Pie20.00
  • Lemon Meringue22.00
  • Minced Meat20.00
  • Mixed Berry22.00
  • Pecan Pie23.00
  • Peach Pie22.00
  • Peanut Butter Dream22.00
  • Pumpkin Pie20.00
  • Rhubarb20.00
  • Strawberry Rhubarb24.00
Pies available by the slice - pricing on our bakery page

Looking for even more baked goods? Visit our Bakery Page. We always do our best to accomodate speical orders. Don't see what you're looking for? Just ask!


  • Milk3.99/half | 5.29/gal
  • Chocolate Milk4.55/half
  • Single Serving Milk Pint1.90ea
  • Whole, Chocolate
  • Airpot Coffee18.20
  • In house only
  • Joe-to-Go32.00
  • Tea2.26/person
  • Iced Tea18.00/half | 27.00/gal
  • Lemonade24.00/half | 34.00/gal
  • Limeade24.00/half | 34.00/gal
  • Cider (seasonal)6.00/half | 8.25/gal
  • Cider Pint (seasonal)3.00ea

  • Single Serving Cheese0.67ea

Signup for Barstow's monthly newsletter