Christmas 2023

The holidays are a time for family and for excellent food! Barstow’s Dairy Store and Bakery offers custom baked goods, pies, cakes, cheesecakes, and desserts for the holiday season.

Christmas orders are due by Monday, December 18 by 4pm.

All orders placed after that time will need baker approval, we may not be able to honor late orders.

So don’t wait! Call us at 413-586-2142 or stop by to place your holiday order!

Pick up is a breeze! Pick up on the day ahead that works best for you. We’ll be open until 3pm on Sunday, December 23, Christmas Eve.


Apple Pie 20.00
Apple Crumb Pie 20.00
Banana Cream Pie 20.00
Blueberry Pie 24.00
Cherry Pie 19.00
Chocolate Cream Pie 20.00
Chocolate Pecan Pie 24.00
Coconut Cream Pie 20.00
Key Lime Pie 20.00
Lemon Meringue 22.00
Minced Meat 22.00
Mixed Berry 22.00
Pecan Pie 23.00
Peanut Butter Dream 22.00
Pumpkin Pie 20.00


Plain 45.00
Chocolate Chip 45.00
Double Chocolate 45.00
Pumpkin 45.00
Choc Peanut Butter 45.00
Choc Butterscotch 45.00
NY Style w/ Cherry 48.00
NY Style w/ Blueberry 48.00
NY Style w/ Strawberry 48.00
Apple Crisp 48.00
Coconut 48.00
Cinnamon Bun 48.00
Cookie Dough 48.00
Turtle 48.00
Bailey’s Irish Cream 48.00
Custom Order

Other favorites

Pan of Cinnamon Swirls
12″ Cookie Platter
18″ Cookie Platter
12″ Mini Pastry Platter
18″ Mini Pastry Platter
12″ Mini Cheesecake Platter
18″ Mini Cheesecake Platter
12″ Assorted Mini Dessert Platter
18″ Assorted Mini Dessert Platter

Find our full offerings on our Bakery Page HERE or on our Catering Page HERE. Questions? Orders? 413-586-2142

Signup for Barstow's monthly newsletter